| Mutation | Prerequisite | Multiplier | Appraisable? | 
| Abyssal | Abyssal Specter Rod increases chance (25% chance) | 3.5x | Yes | 
| Albino | Noir enchantment increases chance (50% chance) | 1.1x | Yes | 
| Amber | n/a | 0.5x | Yes | 
| Anomalous | Must have Anomalous enchantment (20% chance) | 4.44x | No | 
| Ashen Fortune | Must use Volcanic Rod (20% chance) or Magma Rod | 5x | No | 
| Astral | Must fish in an Astral Pool | 6x | No | 
| Atlantean | Must use Trident Rod (30% chance) | 3x | No | 
| Aureate | Must use Auric Rod (20% chance) | 4x | No | 
| Aurelian | Must use Auric Rod (20% chance) | 3x | No | 
| Aureolin | Must use Auric Rod (20% chance) | 5x | No | 
| Aurora | Must use Aurora Rod (15% chance) and Aurora Bait | 6.5x | No | 
| Aurous | Must use Auric Rod (20% chance) | 2x | No | 
| Aurulent | Must use Auric Rod (20% chance) | 5x | No | 
| Awesome | Brick Rod increases chance (5% chance) | 3x | Yes | 
| Blessed | Must use Seraphic Rod (30% chance) or Tryhard Rod (100% chance) | 10x | No | 
| Blighted | Must use Summit Rod (10% chance), Ice Warper's Rod (25% chance), or fish during a Blizzard | 3x | No | 
| Bloom | Must use Free Spirit Rod (20% chance) | 5x | No | 
| Brown Wood | Verdant Shear Rod increases chance (33.3% chance) | 3x | No | 
| Carrot | Carrot Rod increases chance (5% chance) | 8x | Yes | 
| Celestial | Must use Celestial Rod (100% chance during Celestial Bonus) | 3x | No | 
| Chaotic | Must have Chaotic enchantment | 12x | No | 
| Charred | Must use Zeus Rod (10% chance) | 0.5x | No | 
| Cracked | Must use Blazebringer Rod (10% chance) | 3x | No | 
| Crystalized | Must use Crystalized Rod (20% chance) | 3x | No | 
| Cursed Touch | Use the Great Dreamer Rod (5% chance) | 5x | No | 
| Darkened | Noir enchantment increases chances (50% chance) | 1.3x | Yes | 
| Easter | Use the Egg Rod (10% chance) | 4x | No | 
| Electric | Fishing in Grand Reef increases chance (15% chance) | 1.45x | Yes | 
| Electric Shock | Must use Zeus Rod (90% chance) | 3.5x | No | 
| Ember | Must use Blazebringer Rod (15-95% chance) | 3x | No | 
| Emberflame | Must use Blazebringer Rod (5% chance) | 5x | No | 
| Female | n/a | 1x | No | 
| Fossilized | Voyager Rod increases chance (35% chance) | 2.5x | Yes | 
| Frozen | Arctic Rod increases chance (100% chance) | 1.3x | Yes | 
| Glossy | n/a | 1.6x | Yes | 
| Greedy | Rod of the Eternal King (60% chance) and Scurvy Rod (13% chance) increase chance | 4x | Yes | 
| Green Leaf | Verdant Shear Rod increases chance (33.3% chance) | 3x | No | 
| Heavenly | Must use Heaven's Rod (35% chance) | 6x | No | 
| Hexed | No-Life Rod increases chance (50% chance) | 1.5x | Yes | 
| King's Blessing | Must use Poseidon Rod (10% chance) | 3.5x | No | 
| Lightning | Only obtainable in the Zeus Rod Room | 1x | No | 
| Lost | Must use Lost Rod (36% chance) | 5.5x | No | 
| Lunar | Astral Rod and Event Horizon Rod increase chance (5% chance) | 2.5x | Yes | 
| Midas | Midas Rod increases chance (60% chance) | 2x | Yes | 
| Moon-Kissed | Obtainable for 24 hours after catching Moon Idol Sea 1 or 2 (5% chance) | 2.2x | No | 
| Mosaic | n/a | 1.5x | Yes | 
| Mother Nature | Verdant Shear Rod increases chance (33.3% chance) | 3x | No | 
| Mythical | Mythical Rod increases chance (30% chance) | 4.5x | Yes | 
| Negative | n/a | 1.3x | Yes | 
| Nuclear | Only obtainable in areas where a Nuke exploded | 4x | No | 
| Prismize | Must use Etheral Prism Rod (50% chance) | 8x | No | 
| Purified | Only obtainable by bringing an Amber fish to the Chiseler in Ancient Isle | 2x | No | 
| Revitalized | Only obtainable by bringing an Amber fish to the Chiseler in Ancient Isle | 4x | No | 
| Sanguine | Must use Blood Reckoning enchantment | 8x | No | 
| Scorched | Phoenix Rod increases chance (40% chance) | 1.3x | Yes | 
| Seasonal (Spring) | Must use the Seasons Rod during Spring | 3x | No | 
| Seasonal (Summer) | Must use the Seasons Rod during Summer | 1.3x | No | 
| Seasonal (Autumn) | Must use the Seasons Rod during Autumn | 1.3x | No | 
| Seasonal (Winter) | Must use the Seasons Rod during Winter | 2.5x | No | 
| Silver | n/a | 1.6x | Yes | 
| Sleet | Must use Avalanche Rod (25% chance) or during an avalanche | 2.4x | No | 
| Solarblaze | Fang of the Eclipse increases chance (10-90% chance) | 2.5x | No | 
| Stardust | Must use Astralhook Rod (10% chance) | 7.5x | No | 
| Studded | Must use Brick Rod (100% chance) | 1.1x | No | 
| Subspace | Must use Quantum enchantment (25% chance) | 5x | No | 
| Sunken | Must use Sunken Rod (5% chance) | 4x | No | 
| Tentacle Surge | Must use Kraken Rod (5% chance) | 10x | No | 
| Translucent | Ghastly enchantment increases chances (100% chance) | 1.3x | Yes | 
| Umbra | Must use Fang of the Eclipse during an eclipse (10% chance) | 15x | No | 
| Wrath | Only obtainable in the Poseidon Trial Pool waters with Poseidon's Wrath Totem active | 6.5x | No |